Jump To
- What Is Persuasion Analysis?
- The Five Domain Profiles
- The Research Behind It
- How Scoring Works
- Common Patterns in Business Copy
- How Do You Raise a Low Persuasion Score?
- Which domain should I choose for B2B marketing copy?
- Does Persuasion Analysis predict whether people will buy?
- Is persuasion scoring a way to manipulate readers?
What Is Persuasion Analysis?
Persuasion principles are well documented. What the research also shows is that their effect depends on who is reading and what the message is for. Social proof that helps in a sales email can backfire in a health notice. A joke structure that works in a newsletter reads as dismissive in a policy brief.
Persuasion Analysis scores a message against the dimensions that fit its domain, then shows which mechanisms the copy activates and which are missing. It describes what the text is doing. It does not predict how many readers will respond.
Key takeaway
There is no single persuasion score. A message is persuasive in a domain, for an audience.
The Five Domain Profiles
Business
For sales, marketing and B2B or B2C commercial copy: Achievement Motivation, Authority & Credibility, ROI Clarity, Trust Building, Decision Facilitation and Professional Tone.
Health
For health and wellness communication: Medical Accuracy, Safety Compliance, Harm Reduction, Trust & Reassurance and Action Clarity. Accuracy and safety carry the most weight. A health score does not replace review by a qualified person.
Politics
For civic and policy messaging: Frame Effectiveness, Emotional Calibration, Identity Activation, Moral Foundation Alignment, Polarization Management and Civic Engagement.
Identity
For content addressed to an audience with a strongly held identity, such as a profession, a faith, a generation, a region or a gender: Identity Security, Meaning Preservation, Standing Safety, Value Expansion, Autonomy Respect and Exploit & Shame Balance. It scores the message, never the identity, and takes no position on what any identity should look like. Exploiting an identity and talking down to it are flagged with equal weight.
Comedy
For humor in marketing and content: Humor Mechanics, Timing & Rhythm, Audience Calibration, Boundary Respect and Engagement Hook.
The Research Behind It
Principles of influence. Cialdini (1993) synthesized decades of social psychology into six principles: reciprocity, commitment, social proof, authority, liking and scarcity. Persuasion Analysis checks which of them a message uses and whether they suit the domain.
Two routes to persuasion. Petty and Cacioppo's Elaboration Likelihood Model (1986) separates a central route, where readers weigh evidence, from a peripheral route, where they rely on cues and feeling. Copy that works for one route often fails the other, which is why evidence-led and affect-led buyers need different pages.
Tailoring. Noar and colleagues (2007) reviewed 57 studies and found that tailored messages beat generic ones across a wide range of communication outcomes. The aggregate effect is small to modest, and larger under specific conditions.
Story. Green and Brock (2000) showed that being absorbed in a story reduces counterarguing, and van Laer, de Ruyter and Visconti (2014, Journal of Consumer Research) confirmed the pattern across consumer studies.
Curiosity. Loewenstein's information-gap theory (1994) says curiosity comes from noticing a specific gap in what you know. A gap has to be specific to work.
Full references are on the science page.
How Scoring Works
You choose the domain. Each dimension in that profile is scored from 0 to 10, with evidence quoted from your text, and the scores combine into an overall result.
The score reflects how well the copy uses the mechanisms its domain depends on. It does not measure response, and it is not a forecast of results.
Common Patterns in Business Copy
- Authority without proof: "trusted by industry leaders" with no names, numbers or method.
- ROI without a number: a promise of return that gives the reader nothing to check.
- Social proof as decoration: logos on the page, none of them connected to a claim.
- Evidence for the wrong route: a long data table sent to a reader who decides on feel, or a story sent to someone who wants the numbers.
- Pressure in place of facilitation: urgency language where a clear next step would do more.
How Do You Raise a Low Persuasion Score?
- Pick the right domain first. A mismatched profile produces a misleading score.
- Fix the cheap gap first. In business copy that is usually ROI Clarity: add one specific number and say where it comes from.
- Match the route. Decide whether your reader weighs evidence or follows cues, and lead with the matching kind.
- Swap pressure for a clear next step. Decision Facilitation rises when the reader knows exactly what happens next.
Which domain should I choose for B2B marketing copy?
Business. It covers sales emails, landing pages, ads and outbound for business and consumer products. Choose another profile only when the content really belongs to that domain.
Does Persuasion Analysis predict whether people will buy?
No. It scores which persuasion mechanisms the text activates and how well they fit the domain. It does not measure or forecast response.
Is persuasion scoring a way to manipulate readers?
The principles it checks are descriptions of how people already decide. The health and politics profiles weight accuracy, safety and polarization because those domains carry more risk for the reader. SEMalytics diagnoses the draft. What you publish is your decision.
Related frameworks: Framing Strategy, Engagement framework, Identify your audience's personality.